A revision on area ranking and deviation degree methods of ranking fuzzy numbers
نویسندگان
چکیده
Recently two important methods [ \Area ranking of fuzzy numbers based on positive and negative ideal points", Computers and Mathematics with Applications, pp. 1769-1779 (2009)] have been proposed for ranking fuzzy numbers. But we have found that they both have a same basic disadvantage. In this paper, after a short review on diierent proposed fuzzy number ranking methods, we explain the drawback on deviation degree and the area ranking methods and provide an improvement method to overcome this shortage. Our approach is based on the maximization set and minimization set methods concepts. The results show the superiority of the proposed method in comparison with other ranking methods, especially when the ranking of the inverse and the symmetry of the fuzzy numbers are of interest.
منابع مشابه
یک مدل ترکیبی برای رتبه بندی اعداد فازی غیرنرمال
Because of the suitability of fuzzy numbers in representing uncertain values , ranking the fuzzy numbers has widely applications in different sciences. Many models are presented in field of ranking the fuzzy numbers that each one rank based on special criteria and features. The purpose of this paper is presenting a new method for ranking generalized fuzzy numbers based on some parameters such...
متن کاملA novel parametric ranking method for intuitionistic fuzzy numbers
Since the inception of intuitionistic fuzzy sets in 1986, many authors have proposed different methods for ranking intuitionistic fuzzy numbers (IFNs). How ever, due to the complexity of the problem, a method which gives a satisfactory result to all situations is a challenging task. Most of them contained some shortcomings, such as requirement of complicated calculations, inconsistency with hum...
متن کاملREVISION OF SIGN DISTANCE METHOD FOR RANKING OF FUZZY NUMBERS
Recently, Abbasbandy and Asady have been proposed a modificationof the distance based approach, namely ``sign distance method''.However, in this paper, it is shown that this method has some drawbacks, i.e.,the result is not consistent with human intuition for specialcases and this method cannot always logically infer rankingorder of the images of the fuzzy numbers. In this paper, wepresent a re...
متن کاملOn Deviation Degree Methods for Ranking Fuzzy Numbers
Recently, some researchers presented methods for ranking fuzzy numbers based on deviation degree. To avoid more applications that are possible or spread in the future, in this paper, we indicate that the proposed methods have drawbacks. Therefore, they cannot rank fuzzy numbers in all conditions.
متن کاملFuzzy Risk Analysis Based on Ranking of Fuzzy Numbers Via New Magnitude Method
Ranking fuzzy numbers plays a main role in many applied models inreal world and in particular decision-making procedures. In manyproposed methods by other researchers may exist some shortcoming.The most commonly used approaches for ranking fuzzy numbers isbased on defuzzification method. Many ranking fuzzy numberscannot discriminate between two symmetric fuzzy numbers withidentical core. In 200...
متن کامل